Loading slide

What Understanding Actually Is

  1. 01What Understanding Actually Is
  2. 02Back to the feeling
  3. 03The Chinese Room
  4. 04What Searle was saying
  5. 05Memory card
  6. 06The systems reply
  7. 07The Searlese Room
  8. 08It cuts both ways
  9. 09No right answer
  10. 10What humans actually do
  11. 11Does it understand?
  12. 12The line keeps moving
  13. 13Two kinds of intelligence
  14. 14The question Turing left us
  15. 15Reinforce your understanding
  16. 16Question: Chinese Room
  17. 17Question: The systems reply
  18. 18Question: Narrow vs general
  19. 19Quiz: answer
  20. 20Still open
  21. 21Want to go deeper?
6 / 20
BackNext

The systems reply

The sharpest comeback to Searle is the Systems Reply. It goes like this:

Sure, the person alone doesn't understand Chinese. But the whole system does: the person plus the rulebook plus the room. Understanding from the system as a whole, not any single part.

Searle's counter: Okay, imagine the person memorizes the entire rulebook and walks out of the room. Now they are the system. Do they understand Chinese?

The Systems Reply says: Arguably, yes. They've internalized it all.

Searle says: That still feels wrong.

And there it stands. Both sides dig in with solid logic. Neither can land a knockout. That's not philosophy failing. It's the real shape of the question.

Citations(3)↓
  1. 1. uwspace.uwaterloo.ca
  2. 2. plato.stanford.edu
  3. 3. iep.utm.edu