Loading slide

The Summer Everything Seemed Possible

  1. 01The Summer Everything Seemed Possible
  2. 02The summer of the big bet
  3. 03The word they invented
  4. 04The Logic Theorist
  5. 05What the program was actually doing
  6. 06Memory Card
  7. 07Intelligence as search
  8. 08See it for yourself
  9. 09Where search breaks down
  10. 10The size of the problem
  11. 11Just the shape
  12. 12The optimism trap
  13. 13What they got right
  14. 14Reinforce your understanding
  15. 15Question: Logic Theorist
  16. 16Question: The greedy trap
  17. 17Question: The hidden scale
  18. 18Quiz: answer
  19. 19The door was open
  20. 20Want to go deeper?
12 / 19
BackNext

The optimism trap

The researchers of this era did not see those limits yet. They saw the early wins, and they made predictions.

In 1958, Herbert Simon wrote that within ten years a computer would be the world chess champion, prove new mathematical theorems, and compose music of real beauty. The chess champion alone took until 1997, nearly forty years. In 1965 he went further: within twenty years, machines would do any work a person can do.

He was wrong. So was Minsky, who said in 1970 that "within a generation, the problem of creating artificial intelligence will substantially be solved."

These were not idle guesses. They came from careful, serious people who had already built things that worked, then drew a straight line from there to everything else. The line was catastrophically wrong.

Because the problems they had solved were the small, tidy ones. The mazes you can check by hand. They mistook solving those for being almost done.

Citations(2)↓
  1. 1. raysolomonoff.com
  2. 2. cambridge.org